10 Comments

Thanks for this. I just thought that perhaps a ray of hope comes from China, despite the fact that it’s technically one of the highest emitters. First, they make almost everything we use, so a huge portion of their output is ours. Second, China is a global leader in clean energy technologies. https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/29/china-wind-solar-power-global-renewable-energy-leader . They’ve met their clean energy targets 5 years early, and Xi Jinping has promised carbon neutrality by 2060. Yes, they use a lot of coal, but we have to keep in mind that they’re also in a state of Cold War with the US and the West, which hampers their ability to act more boldly. But I think in general, China is a trailblazer, and we can look for examples there of how to make the changes we need. Hell, China would help us here in Canada in a second to transition to clean energy if only we asked.

Expand full comment
Dec 5, 2023Liked by David Moscrop

I feel this and I really struggle with these emotions. Especially in terms of what actions or activities I’m choosing to participate in or not as an individual.

Expand full comment

This is an important feeling for people to work through and even more important that we do it with kindness for each other.

As things get worse, we’re all going to have to get better at the human skills of bonding and understanding.

More will be asked of those of us who can give and we should make ourselves ready to do so.

Expand full comment
Dec 6, 2023Liked by David Moscrop

It really has been so depressing to read what’s coming out of COP. Your piece sent our family down a YouTube memory lane of Davos highlights of those who have called out the hypocrisy over the last few years. It all begins to feel hopeless. As you say, anger is not an unreasonable response. Would love to know how and where to vent that anger productively. Comes back to the role and future of democracy, doesn’t it?

Expand full comment

typo in your titles

Expand full comment

"the hope that we can mobilize those feelings and the interests of the many to remake a society in which we collectively insist on a more just, equitable, and sustainable path for all of us."

That's what's happening, David. Expecting a SMOOTH mobilization would be the height of naivete. There are too many conflicting positions to even idealize "smooth". And who's decided that "the feelings and interests of the many" are the driving forces. Sadly, but practically, the lumpy and bumpy process we've got is the one that will work.

Whether or not it will "work in time" is the decision of any forecaster with enough credibility or naivete to take on the task.

Expand full comment