In his latest book, former Clerk of the Privy Council Alex Himelfarb talks Canadian sovereignty, inequality, the Yankee menace, the climate crisis, and more.
I am concerned that Carney remains a true believer in neo liberalism. He has started revving up the privatization express (or it's shadow expression, "public private partnership") and it is clear that "nation building" so far is 1984-speak for more subsidies and fewer regulations for oil and mining companies. I don't see reason to believe more of the poison that gave us the disease is going to cure us.
Yes. Carney’s links to Palantir, push for AI datacentres across the country, refusal to defend the Canada Health Act, and the fact that Harper is a staunch and vocal supporter of him all make me wary of the pedestal some Canadians are putting him up on.
This is informative and helpful and encouraging. Thanks for it. Can we start calling it something other than “the welfare state”? Even social-safety-net seems more, er, saleable.
>"They’re more persuasion tanks than think tanks."
John Ralston Saul's little dictionary noted that there is no difference in real definition between the three terms, "advertising", "public relations", and "propaganda": just connotation.
I refer to so-called 'research organizations', in posts as "P.R. firms" rather than "think tanks", always noting that "research institutes" publish in peer-reviewed science journals, not the National Post op-eds.
I thus avoid the term "propaganda" but leave any correspondent trying to explain how the Fraser Institute is not just Public Relations for the American Koch network, which a past president did admit to getting much of their funding from.
The term "think tank" should be abolished from political conversation...unless they publish in peer-reviewed journals almost exclusively.
Can we begin by not calling the US "America?" They are The United States, one country in America. So is Canada. I have overlooked that for years, but now names matter. America is a continent with many distinct independent countries in it. It's more accurate refer to the as the US. Adding "of A" is optional.
I don't see how we can break free of neo-liberalism without a serious conversation that re-imagines core concepts like wealth distribution, productivity and what elements are the foundations of a democratic society. Alex is on the right wavelength here, but there's some pretty basic education and rethinking needed on several fronts. For example, a strong case can be made that far from a "drag" on the economy, that public investment is the core foundational piece on which all else depends. It is no accident that the years from 1950 to 1973 that saw sustained growth and development parallels the period when public investments in hospitals, highways, energy projects, housing and infrastructure more generally was a key driving force of economic growth.
Please allow me to reverse the order of a couple of sentences in Mr. Himelfarb's penultimate paragraph, and apply labels:
(A) "... we cannot afford to ignore the struggles of Canadians right now, especially young Canadians, as they deal with record levels of household debt, the high cost of essentials, a precarious labour market, and limited government protections."
(B) "We cannot afford to ... blot out the other “existential” crises and challenges: climate change, record breaking inequality, and the rise of authoritarian and nativist threats to democracy."
To me it seems that an essential part of perpetuating the neoliberal agenda is *precisely* to create and exacerbate (A), in order to distract the maximum number of people from (B), in accordance with Maslow's Hierarchy. (Which, curiously, was invented in the 1940s, at about the same time as the highest aspirations of the United Nations on the one hand, and neoliberalism on the other.)
One generation of politicians (and incessant propaganda from right-wing "think tanks") later, the neoliberal agenda triumphed with the election of Reagan and Thatcher, with Mulroney and the Blairite "New Labour" in the UK following soon thereafter. And fossil fuel companies switched from genuine concern and scientific research on climate change to denying that it even existed.
If neoliberalism has demanded that government remove constraints, it has at the same promoted the idea that government has to get out of the way because the private sector always “does things better”. Hence, for example, the undermining of health care and the slow but sure development of for-profit services.
Pundits like to label like left/right conservative/liberal and measure each action by government that way. It is not black and white but there is a difference between those that only measure $ and those that measure outcome like housing, equity and environment. Coyne last week stated it well, if we have to eg build a pipe line, I'd rather a Liberal do it because it will still encompass those values that are important to me. That is the latitude Carney has been given.
This is a helpful and interesting interview, but my eyebrows are stuck in my hairline from your mistake in the first paragraph. Donald Trump was not re-elected in 2020, excerpt in his own mind. You might want to correct that to 2024...
Fyi I tried all of the options for the epub version of the book from the link in the body of the text and none of them worked although the link did take me to Lorimer the publisher
"I think of neoliberalism as a single-minded focus on economic growth"
Generally I don't like single word labels (or even hyphenated ones). Everyone has their own definition and they usually cover a range of positive to negative connotations.
But I thought it interesting that the notes on the Lorimar web page for the book says:
"Neoliberalism – free market capitalism and the view that “freedom” is society’s highest value – has become embedded in the fabric of Canadian government and society."
Not exactly the same thing is it?
The thing that I think a lot of people left of centre miss is that we don't, and have never had, free market capitalism (which I include to mean a level playing field), that politics has always been in the thrall of capital, even when left of centre governments were in power.
Take for example, how we're taxed. It's become uncontested that consumption taxes are preferable, because they're more economically efficient. So what? When did economic efficiency because the most important criteria? If progressive income taxation is preferable, why is consumption taxation flat? Isn't it obvious that invested wealth benefits from government security just as consumed wealth does? So why should invested wealth get a free ride from the cost of government?
Also, the same argument can be made for anything less than 100% inclusion of capital gains (although I suggest they should be adjusted for inflation). And yet, when the Carter Commission (established by a Conservative government and comprised of very conservative members) suggested that in 1966 (and without an inflation adjustment!), five years later when the Liberal government of the day implemented what it wanted to out of that report, the inclusion rate was set at only 50%. It rose to 66.67% and then 75% under Progressive Conservative governments in the late 80s but was lowered again by a Liberal government in 2000.
Even worse for inequality, estate taxes were dropped in 1972, but were not replaced with a gift/inheritance tax as recommended. (The gift, by way of forgone taxes, to Canada's wealthy families was estimated at $12B at the time.) And principal residence gains were also supposed to be taxed, but with a $25,000 lifetime exemption. How did all these provisions for keeping the playing field level between capital and labour get shunted aside by Liberal governments?
But, getting back to the idea of freedom as the highest value: I suggest that there can never be a single highest value. There can be no freedom (or rights) without responsibility. And individual responsibility (a term I prefer as it seems to have become deprecated, with obvious consequences) is a responsibility not just for oneself and one's actions, but also to the community, because no one, NO ONE, succeeds solely by way of their own effort. Even Isaac Newton wrote, "If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants."
However, having said all that, I still believe that the idea (and empirical data) behind "the wisdom of crowds" points to market forces as a better judge of what markets should provide than small numbers of people in government. Which is not to say governments don't have a foundational role in providing security (including regulation) and infrastructure, but a greater effort in limiting such provisions should be made than has been the case. The thing about privatization vs. government is that private enterprise has both competition and profit as a motivator. You may not like that, but I'm sure that everyone can agree that If governments were perfectly motivated, things would be a lot different. Clearly they're not.
Another quibble on accuracy, the Canada-US FTA was signed in 1988 and went into effect in 1989. NAFTA (which included Mexico) was not implemented until 1991.
1988 was the election that set the course - and yes I use an abbreviated definition in the interview, and the book has a chapter defining neoliberal logic, and it addresses differences between free market liberalism and neoliberalism - and between neoliberalism as ideology and as political project. The book also discusses how neoliberalism treats the wisdom of the crowd with no attention to how some in that crowd accumulate so much wealth and power that it’s their “wisdom” that shapes the world - so, worth a read. Finally while I agree with the Carter recommendations on capital gains I have no idea what the relevance is of which political party did what when. Before the 1980s both PCs and Libs were big tent , mass parties, not what I think of as conviction parties. After the 1980s both were more or less neoliberal. As for freedom being the highest value, I am not saying that for goodness sake. Neoliberals from Hayek to Freedman said it explicitly.
"the relevance is of which political party did what when"
I mentioned it because neo-liberalism is generally associated (and/or conflated) with conservative values. That it's all Reagan/Thatcher/Mulroney's fault with PET et al warning us against it. Not quite. It's part of my ongoing effort to show how political parties in general are the problem, and the problem goes back farther than the 80s.
And I wanted to point out consumption taxes in particular as a quintessentially neo-liberal policy.
The answer that I left out, but have mentioned numerous other times on this channel is that sortition is the answer. It lets the crowd be the crowd without the outsized influence of the few.
I wasn't trying to imply that you were behind the freedom quote. I was offering my own counter to it, as a liberal conservative, but not a neo-liberal.
I remember 1988, my only quibble was your reference to NAFTA in the 80s, when it was only FTA then.
Right. On political parties I and the book agree with you.
And I do not associate neoliberalism with any party. On FTA vs NAFTA, right. In fact I argue that Red Toryism insulated Canada, for a time, from the extreme individualism and worst excesses of neoliberalism.
i take your point and of course we cannot afford soft denialism re climate, inequality etc. But there is a growing global fascist movement - and I am struck by Isabella Weber’s work on anti-fascist economics based on research which shows that the combination of economic shocks, economic insecurity, unaffordable essentials and the lack of adequate protections fuels the turn to far right populism. Of course we need to be tackling the big crises but we cannot ignore those struggling right now.
Himelfarb characterizes Maple MAGA supporters in Canada as a "small northern MAGA rump". This is a serious misjudgment. First , they are not small: about 50% of Conservative Party of Canada members, and probably 30% of the general population. Second, a larger portion of the electorate is at least "MAGA-adjacent", generally supporting extreme libertarian and fascist notions such as eviscerating government, and holding anti-immigration, anti-diversity inclusion, and anti-indigenous sentiments, for example. None of this should be surprising, given what has happened in the US. Make no mistake, the struggle for an independent and non-fascist Canada is ongoing, currently, effectively, a coalition led by the "rump" of the center-right in Canadian politics. And you don't need a plurality to destabilize this effort. A plurality will suffice.
I beg to differ on your numerical estimates. They are, at best 30% of conservatives, which are in turn at most 50% of the population. That puts them at 15% of the population.
Perhaps. But it is the "MAGA-adjacent" that is the real worry. Difficult to gauge, but if it approaches the 40% level--and I believe it will--big problem.
You are right that it’d be a mistake to minimize the risks and yes a strong plurality can do a lot of damage. Especially as we are witnessing a global movement towards fascism and of course we are not immune. (The book addresses these issues more fully.)
It all comes down to the "brandmauer" as they call it in Germany (probably covered in the book). Unfortunately, the brandmauer is currently wobbling in Germany, was crossed in Austria a year before (and reinstated after intense pressure from the EU), has been and is crossed in several Eastern European countries, and is at risk in the UK, France and elsewhere in Europe. The US is unambiguously under a fascist regime currently (yet the mainstream media refuses to acknowledge it), and it is very unclear if this is temporary or a permanent feature. Finally, in Canada a brandmauer "self-organized" in the last federal election vis-a-vis centre-left and centre-right voters moving to the middle. How long this will hold, particularly given the pressure from the south and from within, is also unclear (provincial elections will signal the trend, and so far not looking good). This problem originates at the bottom, amongst the people within the culture, and is not solely economic. It is nurtured and ruthlessly exploited by the craven right, as history has shown. This is the "hard problem" of politics, because, well, it is outside of normal politics.
as for the brandmauer it is always flimsy as the historical evidence indicates that neoliberals fear social democrats and socialists more than they fear fascists
it’s not simply economic of course - fascism isn’t caused by economic factors but the evidence suggests that economic shocks, economic insecurity, unaffordable essentials, and inadequate government protections fuel its growth - throw in plutocrats with more money than many countries and control of powerful media platforms - one can make a strong case that the global spread of fascism is very much though not solely economic
Yes, it is a kindling, no doubt, but I am not convinced it is the primary factor. Most supporters seem to be in the upper percentile of income (I know of several personally in this category, typically lower professionals and/or small business owners (petit bourgeois/Kleinburger as they used to be called)) who seem to harbor a plethora of grievances, some economic, some cultural and some gender-relationship centered. As for economic, it is more the perceived--and real--denial of opportunity and/or status that seems to generate the greatest animus (even Herr Schicklgruber himself, of course, was in this category). Maybe it is not brute economics but the sense of self-worth and recognition that drives a lot of this. Afterall, if it were mainly economics you'd expect the poorest populations around the world to be the most fascistic. This is not the case, however. I think a deeper dive into the psychology and cultural aspects is needed to counter this. Of course, this makes it all much more fraught and difficult given were the (post)post-modern world is heading...Perhaps, we need to view contemporary fascism through a new and more articulated lens.
I am concerned that Carney remains a true believer in neo liberalism. He has started revving up the privatization express (or it's shadow expression, "public private partnership") and it is clear that "nation building" so far is 1984-speak for more subsidies and fewer regulations for oil and mining companies. I don't see reason to believe more of the poison that gave us the disease is going to cure us.
Yes. Carney’s links to Palantir, push for AI datacentres across the country, refusal to defend the Canada Health Act, and the fact that Harper is a staunch and vocal supporter of him all make me wary of the pedestal some Canadians are putting him up on.
Well said.
This is informative and helpful and encouraging. Thanks for it. Can we start calling it something other than “the welfare state”? Even social-safety-net seems more, er, saleable.
>"They’re more persuasion tanks than think tanks."
John Ralston Saul's little dictionary noted that there is no difference in real definition between the three terms, "advertising", "public relations", and "propaganda": just connotation.
I refer to so-called 'research organizations', in posts as "P.R. firms" rather than "think tanks", always noting that "research institutes" publish in peer-reviewed science journals, not the National Post op-eds.
I thus avoid the term "propaganda" but leave any correspondent trying to explain how the Fraser Institute is not just Public Relations for the American Koch network, which a past president did admit to getting much of their funding from.
The term "think tank" should be abolished from political conversation...unless they publish in peer-reviewed journals almost exclusively.
Can we begin by not calling the US "America?" They are The United States, one country in America. So is Canada. I have overlooked that for years, but now names matter. America is a continent with many distinct independent countries in it. It's more accurate refer to the as the US. Adding "of A" is optional.
I don't see how we can break free of neo-liberalism without a serious conversation that re-imagines core concepts like wealth distribution, productivity and what elements are the foundations of a democratic society. Alex is on the right wavelength here, but there's some pretty basic education and rethinking needed on several fronts. For example, a strong case can be made that far from a "drag" on the economy, that public investment is the core foundational piece on which all else depends. It is no accident that the years from 1950 to 1973 that saw sustained growth and development parallels the period when public investments in hospitals, highways, energy projects, housing and infrastructure more generally was a key driving force of economic growth.
agreed - check out chapters 8,9 and 10 of the book
Please allow me to reverse the order of a couple of sentences in Mr. Himelfarb's penultimate paragraph, and apply labels:
(A) "... we cannot afford to ignore the struggles of Canadians right now, especially young Canadians, as they deal with record levels of household debt, the high cost of essentials, a precarious labour market, and limited government protections."
(B) "We cannot afford to ... blot out the other “existential” crises and challenges: climate change, record breaking inequality, and the rise of authoritarian and nativist threats to democracy."
To me it seems that an essential part of perpetuating the neoliberal agenda is *precisely* to create and exacerbate (A), in order to distract the maximum number of people from (B), in accordance with Maslow's Hierarchy. (Which, curiously, was invented in the 1940s, at about the same time as the highest aspirations of the United Nations on the one hand, and neoliberalism on the other.)
One generation of politicians (and incessant propaganda from right-wing "think tanks") later, the neoliberal agenda triumphed with the election of Reagan and Thatcher, with Mulroney and the Blairite "New Labour" in the UK following soon thereafter. And fossil fuel companies switched from genuine concern and scientific research on climate change to denying that it even existed.
If neoliberalism has demanded that government remove constraints, it has at the same promoted the idea that government has to get out of the way because the private sector always “does things better”. Hence, for example, the undermining of health care and the slow but sure development of for-profit services.
Exactly
Tax cuts, deregulation - and privatization - and yes, including healthcare -
Pundits like to label like left/right conservative/liberal and measure each action by government that way. It is not black and white but there is a difference between those that only measure $ and those that measure outcome like housing, equity and environment. Coyne last week stated it well, if we have to eg build a pipe line, I'd rather a Liberal do it because it will still encompass those values that are important to me. That is the latitude Carney has been given.
i don’t think it’s as simple as that
It's not simple
This is a helpful and interesting interview, but my eyebrows are stuck in my hairline from your mistake in the first paragraph. Donald Trump was not re-elected in 2020, excerpt in his own mind. You might want to correct that to 2024...
Threw me off too! 😳
fixed
Great to read your interview...I'll look for the book...
great!
Thank you very much.
Fyi I tried all of the options for the epub version of the book from the link in the body of the text and none of them worked although the link did take me to Lorimer the publisher
ebook not yet out but I will let you know when it is - glad you tried
"I think of neoliberalism as a single-minded focus on economic growth"
Generally I don't like single word labels (or even hyphenated ones). Everyone has their own definition and they usually cover a range of positive to negative connotations.
But I thought it interesting that the notes on the Lorimar web page for the book says:
"Neoliberalism – free market capitalism and the view that “freedom” is society’s highest value – has become embedded in the fabric of Canadian government and society."
Not exactly the same thing is it?
The thing that I think a lot of people left of centre miss is that we don't, and have never had, free market capitalism (which I include to mean a level playing field), that politics has always been in the thrall of capital, even when left of centre governments were in power.
Take for example, how we're taxed. It's become uncontested that consumption taxes are preferable, because they're more economically efficient. So what? When did economic efficiency because the most important criteria? If progressive income taxation is preferable, why is consumption taxation flat? Isn't it obvious that invested wealth benefits from government security just as consumed wealth does? So why should invested wealth get a free ride from the cost of government?
Also, the same argument can be made for anything less than 100% inclusion of capital gains (although I suggest they should be adjusted for inflation). And yet, when the Carter Commission (established by a Conservative government and comprised of very conservative members) suggested that in 1966 (and without an inflation adjustment!), five years later when the Liberal government of the day implemented what it wanted to out of that report, the inclusion rate was set at only 50%. It rose to 66.67% and then 75% under Progressive Conservative governments in the late 80s but was lowered again by a Liberal government in 2000.
Even worse for inequality, estate taxes were dropped in 1972, but were not replaced with a gift/inheritance tax as recommended. (The gift, by way of forgone taxes, to Canada's wealthy families was estimated at $12B at the time.) And principal residence gains were also supposed to be taxed, but with a $25,000 lifetime exemption. How did all these provisions for keeping the playing field level between capital and labour get shunted aside by Liberal governments?
But, getting back to the idea of freedom as the highest value: I suggest that there can never be a single highest value. There can be no freedom (or rights) without responsibility. And individual responsibility (a term I prefer as it seems to have become deprecated, with obvious consequences) is a responsibility not just for oneself and one's actions, but also to the community, because no one, NO ONE, succeeds solely by way of their own effort. Even Isaac Newton wrote, "If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants."
However, having said all that, I still believe that the idea (and empirical data) behind "the wisdom of crowds" points to market forces as a better judge of what markets should provide than small numbers of people in government. Which is not to say governments don't have a foundational role in providing security (including regulation) and infrastructure, but a greater effort in limiting such provisions should be made than has been the case. The thing about privatization vs. government is that private enterprise has both competition and profit as a motivator. You may not like that, but I'm sure that everyone can agree that If governments were perfectly motivated, things would be a lot different. Clearly they're not.
Another quibble on accuracy, the Canada-US FTA was signed in 1988 and went into effect in 1989. NAFTA (which included Mexico) was not implemented until 1991.
1988 was the election that set the course - and yes I use an abbreviated definition in the interview, and the book has a chapter defining neoliberal logic, and it addresses differences between free market liberalism and neoliberalism - and between neoliberalism as ideology and as political project. The book also discusses how neoliberalism treats the wisdom of the crowd with no attention to how some in that crowd accumulate so much wealth and power that it’s their “wisdom” that shapes the world - so, worth a read. Finally while I agree with the Carter recommendations on capital gains I have no idea what the relevance is of which political party did what when. Before the 1980s both PCs and Libs were big tent , mass parties, not what I think of as conviction parties. After the 1980s both were more or less neoliberal. As for freedom being the highest value, I am not saying that for goodness sake. Neoliberals from Hayek to Freedman said it explicitly.
"the relevance is of which political party did what when"
I mentioned it because neo-liberalism is generally associated (and/or conflated) with conservative values. That it's all Reagan/Thatcher/Mulroney's fault with PET et al warning us against it. Not quite. It's part of my ongoing effort to show how political parties in general are the problem, and the problem goes back farther than the 80s.
And I wanted to point out consumption taxes in particular as a quintessentially neo-liberal policy.
The answer that I left out, but have mentioned numerous other times on this channel is that sortition is the answer. It lets the crowd be the crowd without the outsized influence of the few.
I wasn't trying to imply that you were behind the freedom quote. I was offering my own counter to it, as a liberal conservative, but not a neo-liberal.
I remember 1988, my only quibble was your reference to NAFTA in the 80s, when it was only FTA then.
Right. On political parties I and the book agree with you.
And I do not associate neoliberalism with any party. On FTA vs NAFTA, right. In fact I argue that Red Toryism insulated Canada, for a time, from the extreme individualism and worst excesses of neoliberalism.
i take your point and of course we cannot afford soft denialism re climate, inequality etc. But there is a growing global fascist movement - and I am struck by Isabella Weber’s work on anti-fascist economics based on research which shows that the combination of economic shocks, economic insecurity, unaffordable essentials and the lack of adequate protections fuels the turn to far right populism. Of course we need to be tackling the big crises but we cannot ignore those struggling right now.
Himelfarb characterizes Maple MAGA supporters in Canada as a "small northern MAGA rump". This is a serious misjudgment. First , they are not small: about 50% of Conservative Party of Canada members, and probably 30% of the general population. Second, a larger portion of the electorate is at least "MAGA-adjacent", generally supporting extreme libertarian and fascist notions such as eviscerating government, and holding anti-immigration, anti-diversity inclusion, and anti-indigenous sentiments, for example. None of this should be surprising, given what has happened in the US. Make no mistake, the struggle for an independent and non-fascist Canada is ongoing, currently, effectively, a coalition led by the "rump" of the center-right in Canadian politics. And you don't need a plurality to destabilize this effort. A plurality will suffice.
I beg to differ on your numerical estimates. They are, at best 30% of conservatives, which are in turn at most 50% of the population. That puts them at 15% of the population.
Perhaps. But it is the "MAGA-adjacent" that is the real worry. Difficult to gauge, but if it approaches the 40% level--and I believe it will--big problem.
still
You are right that it’d be a mistake to minimize the risks and yes a strong plurality can do a lot of damage. Especially as we are witnessing a global movement towards fascism and of course we are not immune. (The book addresses these issues more fully.)
It all comes down to the "brandmauer" as they call it in Germany (probably covered in the book). Unfortunately, the brandmauer is currently wobbling in Germany, was crossed in Austria a year before (and reinstated after intense pressure from the EU), has been and is crossed in several Eastern European countries, and is at risk in the UK, France and elsewhere in Europe. The US is unambiguously under a fascist regime currently (yet the mainstream media refuses to acknowledge it), and it is very unclear if this is temporary or a permanent feature. Finally, in Canada a brandmauer "self-organized" in the last federal election vis-a-vis centre-left and centre-right voters moving to the middle. How long this will hold, particularly given the pressure from the south and from within, is also unclear (provincial elections will signal the trend, and so far not looking good). This problem originates at the bottom, amongst the people within the culture, and is not solely economic. It is nurtured and ruthlessly exploited by the craven right, as history has shown. This is the "hard problem" of politics, because, well, it is outside of normal politics.
as for the brandmauer it is always flimsy as the historical evidence indicates that neoliberals fear social democrats and socialists more than they fear fascists
it’s not simply economic of course - fascism isn’t caused by economic factors but the evidence suggests that economic shocks, economic insecurity, unaffordable essentials, and inadequate government protections fuel its growth - throw in plutocrats with more money than many countries and control of powerful media platforms - one can make a strong case that the global spread of fascism is very much though not solely economic
Yes, it is a kindling, no doubt, but I am not convinced it is the primary factor. Most supporters seem to be in the upper percentile of income (I know of several personally in this category, typically lower professionals and/or small business owners (petit bourgeois/Kleinburger as they used to be called)) who seem to harbor a plethora of grievances, some economic, some cultural and some gender-relationship centered. As for economic, it is more the perceived--and real--denial of opportunity and/or status that seems to generate the greatest animus (even Herr Schicklgruber himself, of course, was in this category). Maybe it is not brute economics but the sense of self-worth and recognition that drives a lot of this. Afterall, if it were mainly economics you'd expect the poorest populations around the world to be the most fascistic. This is not the case, however. I think a deeper dive into the psychology and cultural aspects is needed to counter this. Of course, this makes it all much more fraught and difficult given were the (post)post-modern world is heading...Perhaps, we need to view contemporary fascism through a new and more articulated lens.
No
No, what?
Break from neoliberalism